Le professeur Gibson a examiné les principales causes, y compris l'affaire Vaid, et il a conclu que la magistrature devait s'assurer que l'exercice du privilège parlementaire dans des cas individuels était conforme aux exigences de la Charte.
Professor Gibson reviewed the leading cases, including the Vaid case, and concludes that the judiciary has a responsibility to ensure that the exercise of parliamentary privilege in individual cases is consistent with Charter requirements.